The 2008 wheat harvest is finished and as predicted by Agmates, this years deregulation of the Australian Export Wheat market has been a nightmare for growers.
What should have been a real one of those catch-up years for wheat growers after years of drought has turned into a lost opportunity.
Australia’s leading grains trading commentator Malcolm Bartholomaeus [pictured], a market analyst for Callum Downs Commodity News and grain grower at Clare in South Australia said:
“Australian grain prices usually correlated highly with prices in Chicago. But this year, instead of being $10 a tonne lower, he said they had been up to $50 a tonne lower, priced off the cheaper Argentinean and Baltic Sea wheat.”
Prior to deregulation there was only one wheat exporter – AWB, now with deregulation there are 20 exporters to deal with and as Bartholomaeus says they are $50 off the Chicago price.
Growers are not dummies and have taken matters into their own hands storing 60-70% of the crop in anticipation of a better prices.
Whilst multinational traders say they are happy with deregulation (of course, they are making money) in hindsight any honest wheat farmer would be filthy on the result. What should have been a very good ‘catch -up-year’ has turned out to be a lost opportunity.
Richard Clark [pictured] , chairman of the NSW Farmers Association grains committee, said:
“You couldn’t have picked a worse year to deregulate than this year.”
Richard Clark said it was a complex harvest that showed:
“just how unprepared the industry was for deregulation. It has turned into a logistics shambles”.
He was critical of the storage and handling systems, the slow start to the shipping program and the low prices.
Wheat growers should in particular be asking those state based farm organizations that supported deregulation how the hell they could have supported a process that has turned out to be clearly detrimental to wheat growers incomes ?
The Victorian Farmers Federation, South Australian Farmers Federation and AgForce in QLD quickly spring to mind.
Perhaps a nice ‘thank you’ letter to those organizations and these Liberal Senators who staunchly supported deregulation, Senators Bill Heffernan, and Judith Adams and Liberal MP’s Wilson Tuckey .And of course lets not forget our brilliant Agriculture Minister Tony Burke.
If you need their contact details for your letter of ‘thanks’ just let me know by way of comment and I’ll post them for you.
Have Your Say!